promised prize

Paintings, drawings and commentary. New ideas on long themes. Simple subtle moments and overt generalizations by Raphael Rice (aka rafirice).

Sunday, April 23, 2006

1st of series: "judenraus"



CLICK on drawing to ENLARGE

Introduction to series:

This is the first cartoon I did in a series that was essentially a response to an invitation to submit holocaust cartoons from President Ahmedinejad of Iran. Dismayed that the European/Islamic culture clashes over Danish Caricatures of the Prophet Muhamed were boiling down to anti-Jewish rhetoric, I set out to intrude upon the invitation and the cartoon form to show a perspective that might bring relief to others as frustrated myself.

The cartoon form, and specifically the political cartoon, has certain demanding parameters which I quickly found to be both a limit and a guide.

The rules are there are no rules but it helps to learn the rules.
I found these rules to be essential;

The cartoon must be honest, even if it is ignorant.
The cartoon should be ironic, but not smug.
The cartoon must fit in a box,
The cartoon should be interesting to look at.
The cartoon must be legible.

Hopefully it's self-explanatory. I can't even approach fairness, but maybe clarity is possible, bridge-building, healing?

I would be happy to receive your thoughts, as well as suggestions for clarifying these drawings or their explanations.

"judenraus":
The action taking place here is of a flashback to WWII Europe. Jews are being collected. Family members peer out of the window as soldiers abruptly interrupt their existence. There may be a habit of belief that a veil of protection surrounds them, particularly since they are still together. Here the curtain is almost drawn for the last moments of this hope. A practical man has made a hiding spot for himself. He says "I wish I were in a Muslim land". At that time there would have been no Irony in that statement. For the most part, throughout the history of Islam, Jews thrived and suffered in Muslim lands as their neighbors did. Class systems offered confinement but also protection and were by no means applied particularly to Jews. Current Iranian supreme leader Ayatollah Khameni said, while rebuking the Iranian president, that anti-Semitism was and continues to be a European problem and not a Muslim one. I feel this statement is also present in this cartoon. I hope my drawing is an olive branch and message to Muslims of our traditional mutual respect. For all the nuances of persecution and liberation in Christian and Muslim lands, systematic genocide was a European creation building to climax on a foundation of rooted and pervasive anti-Semitism. Such a foundation did not exist in Muslim lands before European culture collided with the Middle East in modern history (more on that later).

1 Comments:

  • At 10:44 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

    It is an interesting idea certainly, though there are some defects in presentation of the facts and language.

    I do not have a Massada complex. It seems that it is now accepted that stereotyping people or peoples is wrong, except when this relates to Zionists, who all have Massada complexes or holocaust complexes or something similar.

    Arab hospitality is a custom that was never extended by Arabs to Jews as a group in the land of Israel, or Palestine as it was called between 1917 and 1948. It was extended to individuals. The Sultan invited Jews to live here in the 16th century, but Suleiman was not an Arab but a Muslim and he didn't invite Jews to live in his house, but rather to settle in Turkey and Palestine in order to develop the land.

    You talk about "Palestinian Israelis". I think you have in mind Arabs. Some Israeli Arabs call themselves Palestinians, but they would not be interested
    in living in a Palestinian state. I am a Palestinian Israeli, strictly speaking, though it would be confusing to call myself thus. I am almost as Palestinian as I can be but for one generation. My parents were born in Palestine, or rather Palestine was created by the British mandate with my parents already living in it. They were Palestinians and had Palestinian passports. The Arabs of that day referred to the Jews as "Palestinians" but they referred to themselves as Arabs.


    There are other minor problems here and there.
    Regards

     

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home